| Year | Place | Writer | Work |
| 2012 | First | Michael Simon | The Human Condition |
| Second | Darren Moore | Crimson Typhoon | |
| Third | George Casey | There are other Miners | |
| 2013 | First | Michael Simon | Desperate Times |
| Second | R. Jean Mathieu | The Short, Strange Life of Comrade Lin | |
| Third | Geoffrey Francis | Map of the End of the World | |
| Honorable Mention | Danny Knestaut | Blue | |
| 2014 | No Award | ||
| 2015 | First | Sean Gillhoolley | The Bazaar of Forbidden Dreams |
| Second | Jeff Spitzer | The Last Ordeal of James Willoughby | |
| Third | Kristin Janz | Fabiana’s Fairy Godmother | |
| Honorable Mention | Deborah Rocheleau | Track Invasion | |
| 2016 | First | Robert N. Stephenson | Moonhenge |
| Second | Michael Simon | Natural Selection | |
| Third | Frank Sawielijew | Beyond the Spires | |
| Honorable Mention | Gustavo Bondoni | Free Fall | |
| 2017 | First | Philip A. Kramer | Quantum Quietus |
| Second | Gustavo Bondoni | Qualnoth’s Favor | |
| Third | Robert W. Jennings | Trash Smashers | |
| Honorable Mention | Graham J. Darling | Immaterial Witness | |
| 2018 | First | Gustavo Bondoni | Iced |
| Second | Graham J. Darling | The Tim Machine | |
| Third | Michael Simon | The Answer | |
| Honorable Mention | Karen L. Kobylarz | Talisman and Bone | |
| 2019 | First | Karen L. Kobylarz | As Day Follows Night |
| Second | Gustavo Bondoni | The Safety of Thick Walls | |
| Third | Adam R. Goss | Where you G-O-H When You Die | |
| Honorable Mention | Michael Simon | The Captain | |
| 2020 | First | Chris Owens | The Azazel Tree |
| Second | John Yarrow | The Eternal Secret | |
| Third | Jack Mulcahy | If Music Be the Fruit of Love | |
| Honorable Mention | Charles Douglas | The Haunting of the Jabberwocky | |
| 2021 | First | Sean Jones | The Prudence of Silver |
| Second | Adrian Rayner | Breaking Good | |
| Third | Markus Nyström | Wear Some Flowers In Your Hair | |
| Honorable Mention | Patrick McKay | The Landing at the Somme | |
| 2022 | First | Sean Jones | From Invention Springs Necessity |
| Second | Clint Stevenson | After the Siege | |
| Third | A.C. Cargill | Book of Memories | |
| Honorable Mention | Guy Lillian | The Candlestick Maker | |
| 2023 | First | Clint Ste- venson |
Island of Avarice |
| Second | Charles Walter | Denebolan Marathon | |
| Third | J.L. Cook | Forged in Fire | |
| Honorable Mention | Jeff Cassell | Welcome to Vulpye |
